Two Auckland real estate agents have lost appeals after advertising that a homeowner had bought another property unconditionally and needed a quick sale, without obtaining informed approval for the wording.
The Real Estate Agents Disciplinary Tribunal upheld unsatisfactory conduct findings against Winston Kidd and Lewis Caunter in a decision dated 16 November 2026.
Caunter’s $2,000 fine and Kidd’s $1,500 fine remained in place, alongside Kidd’s censure and a referral to consider compensation for the vendor.
The case raises a question for homeowners signing off a marketing campaign. How much of your personal financial position should an agent tell prospective buyers?
SELLER APPROVED A NEW STRATEGY
According to Stuff’s report, the vendor engaged the agents’ firm in January 2024 while purchasing another property.
Caunter appraised the Auckland home at between $1.08 million and $1.32 million. The vendor said his onward purchase depended on achieving at least $1.2 million.
After an unsuccessful auction campaign, buyers offered $1.1 million on 20 March 2024. The resulting agreement was unconditional, but the buyers failed to pay the deposit and defaulted.
Stuff reported that Caunter waited until 9 April to tell the vendor the deposit remained unpaid. The vendor needed bridging finance for the replacement property.
The owner subsequently agreed to an asking price of $1.1 million, telling Caunter on 21 April that he would accept no less.
A week later, the marketing changed.
WHAT THE ADVERTISEMENT REVEALED
On 29 April, Caunter emailed the vendor to say the online heading and copy had been changed to encourage buyers to act. The vendor replied with thanks.
The revised listing announced that the owner had bought unconditionally. Its description told buyers the property needed to sell as soon as possible.
Those statements revealed the seller’s circumstances and signalled pressure to secure a sale.
The home sold on 2 May 2024 for $1.005 million, which was $95,000 below the vendor’s stated minimum. The vendor complained to the Real Estate Authority in August.
That price difference was part of the background to the dispute. The appeal decision upheld a referral to consider compensation, leaving that process to address any compensable loss connected to the conduct.
Related Property Noise coverage — Harcourts agents censured over an EQC payout on a $1.8 million home
WHY THE AGENTS CHALLENGED THE FINDINGS
Counsel for Kidd and Caunter argued that the revised marketing strategy had the vendor’s knowledge and approval.
The owner maintained he had never been shown the specific wording before publication.
The tribunal accepted that the vendor had approved a change in strategy. It found no evidence of approval for the words revealing his circumstances and apparent urgency.
That distinction mattered because the information could weaken his negotiating position. The tribunal concluded that the circumstances required informed approval before publication.
It upheld the finding that the agents had breached rule 5.1 of the Professional Conduct and Client Care Rules, which concerns skill, care, competence and diligence.
WHY A SELLER’S CIRCUMSTANCES MATTER TO BUYERS
An advertisement can influence more than how many people attend an open home. It can also shape what those buyers think they need to offer.
A buyer who learns the owner has committed to another purchase may consider whether the seller has a deadline or additional holding costs. Wording that emphasises urgency can invite buyers to test how much flexibility exists on price.
For a vendor, that makes approval of the actual advertisement a significant part of the campaign.
The ruling shows why agreement to refresh a listing needs to cover potentially disadvantageous information the revised copy will disclose. A seller may welcome a more energetic campaign while wanting to keep the details of an onward purchase private.
Related Property Noise coverage — Should New Zealand end “price on enquiry” property advertising?
THE UNPAID DEPOSIT WAS A SEPARATE ISSUE
Stuff reported that Caunter did not appeal the separate finding concerning his delay in communicating the unpaid deposit.
The agency was also censured and fined $5,000.
The failed first sale, bridging finance and revised campaign placed the owner in a difficult position. Keeping him informed about the deposit and obtaining approval for sensitive marketing information were separate responsibilities within that transaction.
WHAT HOMEOWNERS CAN ASK BEFORE AN AD GOES LIVE
For sellers reviewing a campaign, the case provides several useful questions to put to their agent.
• Can I see the exact heading and description before publication?
• Which details about my circumstances will you disclose to buyers?
• How could those details affect negotiations?
• How will you obtain my approval if the wording changes?
• What will you tell buyers who ask why I am selling or how quickly I need to move?
The vendor’s circumstances can form part of a marketing strategy, but the seller needs the opportunity to make an informed decision about that disclosure.
In this case, the tribunal found the necessary approval was missing. The agents’ appeals were dismissed.
Reporting draws on Stuff’s 19 November report and the Ministry of Justice summary of Kidd & Caunter v REAA (CAC 2405) & NL [2026] NZREADT 55.

