Rents on new tenancies are up about 1% nationally, according to ANZ. In Auckland’s Mount Wellington, a suburb-level comparison shows a $269-a-week gap between median rent and an illustrative mortgage repayment.

New Zealand renters waiting for house prices to fall might have expected the move into home ownership to get easier. A lower purchase price can shrink the deposit they need. But if their next rental costs more and mortgage rates are higher by the time they buy, the weekly budget can still get tighter.

ANZ’s November/December Property Focus says rents on new tenancies are about 1% higher than a year ago after a period of decline. That figure tracks rents agreed when a new tenancy starts. The Reserve Bank, meanwhile, says the housing market has softened over the past six months, with continued weakness in Auckland and Wellington and stronger conditions in parts of the South Island. ANZ Property Focus · Reserve Bank Financial Stability Report For homeowners and investors

Why are NZ rents rising while house prices fall?

A house sale depends on what buyers can borrow and what they are willing to offer. When mortgage rates rise, the same loan costs more to service. Some buyers lower their bids, and others wait. If there are plenty of listings, sellers face more competition for the buyers who are still looking.

Rents depend more on how many households are looking for a place to live and how many suitable rentals are available. ANZ says the gradual economic recovery has helped lift rental demand, while new housing supply has kept rent growth subdued. That helps explain how rents on new leases can edge up while sale prices stay under pressure. ANZ Property Focus For homeowners and investors

Read more: Why better times may not bring a NZ house price boom. Property Noise

Rent vs buy in Mount Wellington: $650 rent or a $919 mortgage?

Realestate.co.nz’s 12-month suburb figures put Mount Wellington’s median weekly rent at $650 and its REINZ-supplied median sale price at $876,660. The local rental figure was down 2.3% on the previous 12 months, while the median sale price was down 3.2%. The rolling suburb figures and ANZ’s national new-tenancy measure cover different markets and periods. Mount Wellington market insights realestate.co.nz

Mount Wellington comparison Amount
Median advertised rent $650 a week
Median sale price $876,660
Illustrative 20% deposit $175,332
Mortgage after deposit $701,328
Mortgage at 5.5% over 30 years About $919 a week
Mortgage at 6.5% over 30 years About $1,023 a week

The rental and sale figures are separate suburb medians across a mix of properties. The example uses illustrative rates and converts monthly principal-and-interest repayments to weekly equivalents. Ownership costs such as council rates, insurance, maintenance and any body corporate levies are extra. Property Noise mortgage repayment calculator realestate.co.nz

Does falling house prices make it easier to buy?

A price drop can make a real difference to someone saving a deposit. A $50,000 reduction cuts a 20% deposit target by $10,000 and leaves the buyer borrowing $40,000 less. A slower market can also give buyers more time to compare properties and negotiate, a theme Property Noise covered in its look at why Auckland buyers still hold the cards. Property Noise

The mortgage rate can absorb the entire repayment saving. On a $900,000 purchase with a 20% deposit, a 30-year mortgage at 5% costs about $892 a week. Drop the purchase price to $850,000, keep the same deposit percentage and lift the rate to 5.5%, and the repayment is still about $891 a week. The buyer gets in with $10,000 less upfront, but the weekly repayment barely moves. Property Noise mortgage repayment calculator Property Noise

When does renting still make sense?

At $650 a week, the Mount Wellington renter has around $269 more each week than the buyer paying a 5.5% mortgage, even before the buyer’s rates, insurance and maintenance. For a household that can save some of that difference, staying put can help build the deposit. For a household that has to move and sign a more expensive lease, some of that saving disappears.

Buying brings more control over the home and a chance to build equity as the loan balance falls. In this example, the buyer would repay about $9,450 in principal in the first year at 5.5%. The trade-off is committing the deposit upfront and carrying the ongoing costs of ownership, with repayments potentially changing at the next refix.

That’s the affordability question a falling house-price headline leaves open. Can you get the deposit together, and can you still afford the home once you have the keys? In today’s market, those two answers can move in different directions.

Would you keep renting at $650 a week or buy at roughly $919 a week before rates, insurance and upkeep? What would make you take the leap?